The Forge Shop

The Store

14,062 items in stock across every game we carry — search anything, or drill into a game on the left.

14,062 items

2 in stockImperious Perfect - Foil
Imperious Perfect - Foil
Lorwyn · ✦ Foil LP
$10.70
1 in stockImpetuous Devils
Impetuous Devils
Eldritch moon NM
$0.25
3 in stockImpetuous Devils
Impetuous Devils
Eldritch moon LP
$0.25
20 in stockImposing Challenger
Imposing Challenger
Unleashed NM
$0.25
3 in stockImpostor Syndrome
Impostor Syndrome
Marvel's Spider-Man NM
$6.81
6 in stockImprisoned
Imprisoned
Shadows of the Galaxy NM
$0.25
1 in stockImprisoned in the Moon
Imprisoned in the Moon
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal NM Borderless
$3.06
1 in stockImprisoned in the Moon
Imprisoned in the Moon
Avatar: The Last Airbender Eternal · ✦ Foil NM Borderless
$6.06
2 in stockImprisoned in the Moon
Imprisoned in the Moon
Eldritch moon NM
$0.32
3 in stockImpropriety Among Thieves
Impropriety Among Thieves
Twilight of the Republic NM
$0.25
1 in stockImpropriety Among Thieves - Foil
Impropriety Among Thieves - Foil
Twilight of the Republic · ✦ Foil NM
$0.27
1 in stockImprovisation Capstone
Improvisation Capstone
Secrets of Strixhaven NM
$10.08
1 in stockImprovised Arsenal - Extended Art
Improvised Arsenal - Extended Art
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles NM Extended Art
$1.87
1 in stockImpulse
Impulse
Dominaria Remastered NM
$0.25
1 in stockImpulse
Impulse
Dominaria United NM
$0.37
2 in stockImpulse - Foil
Impulse - Foil
Dominaria Remastered · ✦ Foil NM
$0.29
1 in stockImskir Iron-Eater
Imskir Iron-Eater
Modern Horizons 3 NM
$0.32
1 in stockImskir Iron-Eater - Borderless
Imskir Iron-Eater - Borderless
Modern Horizons 3 NM Borderless
$0.60
1 in stock
In a Nut Shell
In a Nut Shell
Board Games SEALED
$20.99
4 in stockIn Defense of Kamino
In Defense of Kamino
Twilight of the Republic NM
$0.25
1 in stockIn Defense of Kamino - Foil
In Defense of Kamino - Foil
Twilight of the Republic · ✦ Foil NM
$0.39
3 in stockIn Search of Greatness
In Search of Greatness
Kaldheim NM
$0.43
7 in stockIn the Heat of Battle
In the Heat of Battle
Jump to Lightspeed NM
$0.25
2 in stockIn the Heat of Battle - Foil
In the Heat of Battle - Foil
Jump to Lightspeed · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
1 in stockIn the Heat of Battle - Hyperspace
In the Heat of Battle - Hyperspace
Jump to Lightspeed · ✦ Hyperspace NM
$0.25
1 in stockIn the Heat of Battle - Hyperspace - Foil
In the Heat of Battle - Hyperspace - Foil
Jump to Lightspeed · ✦ Foil NM
$0.25
2 in stock
In the Swing (Red) - Rainbow Foil - 1st Edition
In the Swing (Red) - Rainbow Foil - 1st Edition
Everfest · ✦ Rainbow Foil NM
$0.32
4 in stockIn the Trenches
In the Trenches
The Brothers' War NM
$0.40
1 in stockIn the Trenches - Extended Art
In the Trenches - Extended Art
The Brothers' War NM Extended Art
$0.78
1 in stockIn the Trenches - Rainbow Foil
In the Trenches - Rainbow Foil
Secret Lair Drop Series · ✦ Rainbow Foil NM
$1.84
Special orderInago Medium Walker (2025 reformat of the Japanese Locust)
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Inago Medium Walker (2025 reformat of the Japanese Locust)
Konflikt '47 & Sci-Fi SEALED
$63.18 $66.50 5% off
1 in stockIncarnation Technique
Incarnation Technique
Commander 2021 NM
$9.35
1 in stockIncisor Glider
Incisor Glider
Phyrexia: All Will Be One NM
$0.25
1 in stockIncreasing Ambition
Increasing Ambition
Dark Ascension NM
$2.64
4 in stockIncreasing Confusion
Increasing Confusion
Dark Ascension NM
$0.93
2 in stockIncreasing Devotion
Increasing Devotion
Dark Ascension NM
$0.25
1 in stockIncreasing Savagery
Increasing Savagery
Dark Ascension NM
$0.43
2 in stockIncreasing Vengeance
Increasing Vengeance
Dark Ascension NM
$0.86
1 in stockIncreasing Vengeance - Foil
Increasing Vengeance - Foil
Strixhaven: Mystical Archives · ✦ Foil NM
$9.08
2 in stockIncubation // Incongruity - Foil
Incubation // Incongruity - Foil
Ravnica Allegiance · ✦ Foil NM
$0.90
1 in stockIndatha Triome
Indatha Triome
Ikoria: Lair of Behemoths NM
$16.61
1 in stockIndebted Spirit
Indebted Spirit
Modern Horizons 3 NM
$0.25
1 in stockIndestructibility
Indestructibility
Magic 2010 NM
$1.11
1 in stockIndestructible Aura
Indestructible Aura
Legends NM
$0.49
2 in stockIndestructible Aura
Indestructible Aura
Legends LP
$0.48
5 in stockInduced Amnesia
Induced Amnesia
Rivals of Ixalan NM
$0.25
5 in stockInduction Chamber
Induction Chamber
History Pack Vol.1 NM
$0.31
1 in stockInduction Chamber - Rainbow Foil - Unlimited Edition
Induction Chamber - Rainbow Foil - Unlimited Edition
Arcane Rising · ✦ Rainbow Foil NM
$1.21
1 in stockIndulgent Tormentor
Indulgent Tormentor
Magic 2015 LP
$0.92
1 in stockIndulgent Tormentor
Indulgent Tormentor
Starter Commander Decks NM
$0.87
3 in stockInevitable Betrayal
Inevitable Betrayal
Modern Horizons 2 NM
$1.25
4 in stockInexorable Blob
Inexorable Blob
Shadows Over Innistrad NM
$0.26
Special orderInfantry bases pack
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Infantry bases pack
Historical SEALED
$17.00
Special orderInfantry of the Grand Alliance
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Infantry of the Grand Alliance
Historical SEALED
$40.00
Special orderInfantry of the Sun King
Special order · we’ll bring it in · pickup in ~1–2 wks
Infantry of the Sun King
Historical SEALED
$40.00
65 in stockInferna
Inferna
Unleashed NM
$0.25
4 in stockInfernal Reckoning
Infernal Reckoning
Core Set 2019 NM
$0.31
1 in stockInfernal Tribute
Infernal Tribute
Weatherlight NM
$2.96
4 in stockInfernal Tutor - Retro Frame
Infernal Tutor - Retro Frame
Ravnica Remastered NM Retro Frame
$0.54
2 in stockInfernal Vessel
Infernal Vessel
Foundations NM
$0.25